The 51 Best Pizzerias in New York City

The following is an aggregate list based off of 213 different "Best Pizzerias in New York City" lists. Ties represent an establishment showing up on the same number of lists. (updated as of 4/21/26)

1. Joe's - West Village, Manhattan
2. Di Fara - Midwood, Brooklyn
3. Roberta's - Williamsburg, Brooklyn
4. John's of Bleecker Street - West Village, Manhattan
5. Prince St. Pizza - Nolita, Manhattan
5. Patsy's - East Harlem, Manhattan
5. Lucali - Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
8. L&B Spumoni Gardens - Gravesend, Brooklyn
9. Paulie Gee's - Greenpoint, Brooklyn
10. Artichoke Basille - East Village, Manhattan
10. Rubirosa Ristorante - Nolita, Manhattan
12. Motorino - East Village, Manhattan
13. Scarr's - East Village, Manhattan
14. Lombardi's - Nolita, Manhattan
15. Best Pizza - Williamsburg, Brooklyn
16. Totonno's - Coney Island, Brooklyn
17. L'Industrie - Williamsburg, Brooklyn
18. Joe & Pat's Pizzeria - Castleton Corners, Staten Island
18. Kesté - West Village, Manhattan
18. Mama's Too - West Village, Manhattan
21. Louie & Ernie's - Schuylerville, Bronx
22. Una Pizza Napoletana - East Village, Manhattan
23. Bleecker Street Pizza - West Village, Manhattan
23. New York Pizza Suprema - Chelsea, Manhattan
25. Juliana's Pizza - DUMBO, Brooklyn
25. Don Antonio by Starita - Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan
27. Speedy Romeo - Clinton Hill, Brooklyn
27. Denino's - Elm Park, Staten Island
29. Emily - Clinton Hill, Brooklyn
29. Ops - Bushwick, Brooklyn
29. Zero Otto Nove - Belmont, Bronx
32. Grimaldi's - DUMBO, Brooklyn
33. Emmy Squared - East Village, Manhattan
34. Ribalta - West Village, Manhattan
35. Sal & Carmine's Pizza - Upper West Side, Manhattan
36. New Park Pizza - Howard Beach, Queens
37. Rizzo's Fine Pizza - Astoria, Queens
37. Sottocasa Pizzeria - Boerum Hill, Brooklyn
37. Williamsburg Pizza - Williamsburg, Brooklyn
37. Pasquale Jones - Little Italy, Manhattan
41. Corner Slice - Midtown, Manhattan
42. Emmett's - SoHo, Manhattan
42. Lee's Tavern - Dongan Hills, Staten Island
42. Lucia Pizza - Flushing, Queens
45. Upside Pizza - Greenpoint, Brooklyn
46. Arturo's - West Village, Manhattan
46. Luzzo's - East Village, Manhattan
46. Two Boots Pizza - East Village, Manhattan
46. Nick's Pizza - Forest Hills, Queens
46. Milkflower - Astoria, Queens